Review :: Grid 2

Grinding across the finish line...

Brenden Mernargh

Written by Brenden Mernagh - Staff Writer

Published Wednesday, 07 August 2013 14:07

Write your own review !

grid 2 - screenshot 02-f

 

 

Codemasters Grid was one of the milestone racing titles of this generation.  It featured a wonderful blend between simulation and arcade racing and innovated some fun new mechanics that, while not revolutionizing the racing genre, certainly helped redefine what the status quo should be for a next-gen racer.  But that was 2008 and this is 2013, and as we gradually witness the twilight of this console generation, this sequel begs the question: Is status quo from 2008 acceptable in 2013?  

 

In short, Grid 2 does a lot of things well.  The fundamentals of a good racing game are in place.  The only problem is that unlike Grid, Grid 2 never gives you a reason to keep playing.  This racing gets boring--- fast (pun shamefully intended).  But it’s not just the bland gameplay that keeps Grid 2 from reaching its predecessors heights, it’s the convoluted menu screens, inconsistent controls, bland tracks, and weak multiplayer component.

 

The single-player component of Grid 2 involves a hokey narrative about how you must earn fans via a made-up social media site through “video uploads” of your past performances (think YouTube and followers and views), create a fictional World Series Racing league (the aptly named WSR), and be the best racer in the fictional racing league that you helped create.  The generic narrative, however, left me with no real vested interest in anything that was going on.  As I completed races and unlocked new fans, I felt bored and uninterested.  None of this was helped by the inconsistent control of the cars and the bland derivative tracks.  But, even then, I wanted to feel a sense of place, a sense that this world, this narrative was as carefully crafted as the beautiful looking cars in it.  I just never felt that, though.

 

The inconsistent control of the cars is probably one of the weakest elements of Grid 2.  Each car felt incredibly different.  This is fine and realistic and for the most part should be desired from a racer; the only problem with Grid 2’s feel, however, is that some cars feel like they are operating by a completely different set of physical laws than other cars.  That is to say, some cars feel like they are floating on the track, while others feel like they weigh as much as a tank.  I would avoid using some cars completely because I felt they simply were un-drivable.  No racer should make you feel this way. And maybe it was my lack of skill, or my ignorance to the rules of the game, but I never wanted to learn how to control those difficult to control cars, it just wasn’t going to be any fun.  

 

The locations and tracks in the game also left me with a feeling of nausea.  As a racing fan, I had seen this all before.  Want to race through the streets of Paris or Rome?  Haven’t we done that already?  Want to race at sunset with the glare of the falling sun in your view?  Did I not see that in Gran Turismo on the PS2?  Oh, yeah, I did.  This is all just more of the same.  

 

Due to the inconsistent controls Grid 2 feels incredibly difficult.  I never had the sense that I was getting better after the completion of a race.  I have also never faced a more competitive and aggressive A.I.  Trying to effectively overtake any car was a challenge, as oftentimes they would crash into you when you tried, effectively taking you out of the race.  Cars that are behind, meanwhile, have a distinct ability to knock your car off balance and send you spinning into a wall.  When you try the same technique on those same A.I. cars, your car goes spinning out of control while the A.I. operated car races off unaffected.  You are operating with a different set of rules than the A.I. and that is usually the sign of a poorly made game.  

 

 

If there is one area where this game shines it is in the visuals.  This was one of the sharpest looking racing games I have ever played.  Each track is impeccably detailed and the locations look like their real-world counterparts.  While some courses tend to over use the aforementioned sun-glare effect, this is a relatively minor complaint when one considers how good the game looks overall.  There is also a nice sense of speed while you race, and the “rewind” ability (which allows you to rewind your progress if you make a mistake) demonstrates the games great particle effects.  The same praise can also be given to the games overall sound.  The soundtrack is very reminiscent of Daft Punk’s “Tron:Legacy” soundtrack and that is not entirely a bad thing.  Aesthetically, this game is an impressive display of current-gen tech.

 

Grid 2 is guilty of an awful UI-- nothing seems to work the way you think it will.  What’s worse is the fact that the UI changes mid-game, so while you may feel like you finally have a grip on where certain buttons are you must re-learn some of it as you progress.  I don’t know what it is, but sports/racing titles seem to be guilty of this crime more than any other.  There is too much flash to the UI and nothing seems easy to figure out.  It really is a style over substance matter and it’s one I hope next-gen titles don’t suffer from.  So while it is difficult to criticize Grid 2 of its UI when similar games suffer from the same glaring attribute, I feel it is worth noting if only so future developers take note and start making game UIs a little more intuitive.  

 

race-driver-grid-2 02A8000000112201

 

 

The multiplayer component was a little dull as it offered nothing competitive or exciting.  It was instead crippled by the incompetent UI, slow loading times, and the poor control of the cars.  When I did find a challenger the matches lasted too long and never felt compelling.  

 

Racing games are about the sense of speed and control.  Grid 2 offers plenty of speed but hardly any control.  The graphics and sound are top-notch but every thing else leaves much to be desired.  Grid 2 seems to want the best of both worlds: it wants to as much to be a racing simulator as it does an arcade racing game.  Clearly Codemasters knows how to make a quality racing game as made evident by the original Grid, but Grid 2 never reaches those solid heights.  To say I had no fun playing Grid 2 would be a lie, it’s just that the fun I had was intermittent and never lasted long. Overall, Grid 2s biggest fault is it’s inconsistency-- a fault which I hope will be fixed with Codemasters next-gen titles.  

 

 

 

 


Pros

+ Great sound and graphics 

Cons

- inconsistent controls

- bland, derivative courses

- weak multiplayer

- weak single-player campaign

 

 

 


Final rating
7.0 / 10
Comments
More Xbox 360 reviews
2014-04-06 :: Dark Souls II
2013-11-12 :: Alien Rage
2013-09-17 :: Grand Theft Auto V
2013-09-15 :: Lost Planet 3
2013-09-13 :: Splinter Cell: Blacklist
2013-07-26 :: Remember Me
2013-07-23 :: (XBLA) Sanctum 2
2013-06-05 :: Star Trek
Special articles
The 10 Types of Gamers Special articles

The 10 Types of Gamers

  This list isn’t to marginalize a particular group of Gamers but rather to celebrate our differences.  Also, I don’t think it’s possible to be just one type of gamer either, you can be all sorts.  So enjoy my list of the “10 Types of Gamers” and let me know if I missed one or what type of gamer you are in the comments section below!
Lire la suite...
The Best and The Worst: Titanfall Maps Special articles

The Best and The Worst: Titanfall Maps

Since everybody loves lists and since everybody also loves Titanfall, I thought it was pertinent that I combine these two equally loved things together.  And since maps are one of the key ingredients in a first-person shooter, I felt that would be a good place to start: Read more
More with Titanfall's Lead Game Director Steve Fukuda Special articles

More with Titanfall's Lead Game Director Steve Fukuda

 Last week Andrew Atkinson posted a great piece on the interview he and I had with Titanfall’s Lead Game Director, Steve Fukuda.  I thought I would follow up with some more little bits of information we were able to gather from Mr. Fukuda detailing what’s in store for Titanfall in the future: Read more
Five Things we Learned from 'Titanfall' Lead Developer Steve Fukuda Special articles

Five Things we Learned from 'Titanfall' Lead Developer Steve Fukuda

Gamefocus recently had the chance to chat with Steve Fukuda, lead game developer for Titanfall at Respawn.  Fukuda was lead designer at Infinity Ward where he was a major player in the production of the Call of Duty series up until Modern Warfare 2.  Brenden Mernagh and I arranged to speak with Fukuda at the Titanfalllaunch party in Toronto. Read more

Game details
Grid 2
Release date : 2013-05-28
Platform :
Publisher : Codemasters
Developer : Codemasters
Gameplay : Racing

DLC Talk

DLC Talk: Bioshock: Burial at Sea Ep. 1

DLC Talk: Bioshock: Burial at Sea Ep. 1

Here we are. The next generation of consoles is among us and it is finally time to start thinking about finally unplugging our beloved current-gen systems. Could there be a better swan song for one of these systems than taking a trip back to Rapture?


Read more

DLC Talk: Dishonored - The Knife of Dunwall

DLC Talk: Dishonored - The Knife of Dunwall

Dishonored: The Knife of Dunwall is an impressive little bit of DLC. I should emphasize “little” though, as it is a relatively short experience. Just when the story seems to get going it ends - or, rather, it “kind of” ends.


Read more

DLC Talk: Dragon’s Dogma: Dark Arisen

DLC Talk: Dragon’s Dogma: Dark Arisen

Dragon’s Dogma was released last year on PlayStation 3 and Xbox 360.


Read more
GF Blogs

Rage Against The Exploding Barrel

Rage Against The Exploding Barrel

In the year 1981 a decision was made which would forever alter the face of video games as we know them. A young gorilla named Donkey Kong was throwing wooden barrels at a spunky little plumber named Mario. What happened next influenced the level design and gameplay of most FPS and adventure games since.


Read more

Why Super Nintendo VS Sega Genesis is a lot like PS4 VS Xbox One

Why Super Nintendo VS Sega Genesis is a lot like PS4 VS Xbox One

The video game press and blogosphere didn’t really know what to make of the Playstation 4 and the Xbox One when they were announced last year.  Most of this confusion seemed to stem from the fact that no one really knew for sure if these next-generation video game consoles would offer the player anything new.  Yes, there would be better graphics, better online functionality, a better multimedia experience, and a better controller, but would that be it?


Read more

'Goat Simulator' is Live! You can Virtually Live as a Goat!

'Goat Simulator' is Live! You can Virtually Live as a Goat!

I’ve often thought that what the animal rights movement really needs are some rocking simulations of animal life.  I’m not sure Goat Simulator will offer that (I’m still downloading it), but think about this: imagine teaching a grade seven science class where you hook your students up to Oculus Rift VR sets, fix them with some haptic arm and leg bands, and send them out to join a wolf pack stalking caribou in the arctic tundra (Dire Wolf!).


Read more
GameFocus Radio

GameFocus Podcast: December 16, 2013

GameFocus Podcast: December 16, 2013

Game Focus is proud to present its new podcast episode, a weekly casual talk between GameFocus staff members about the gaming industry. In this show, we talk about mostly the Xbox One and the PS4. Vince explains in details what happened when he reached Microsoft support for a problem with his Xbox One that unexpectedly died after less than 2 days of use.

Read more
GameFocus 2014 Top 10
2
Dark Souls II (Xbox 360)
9.1
3
9.0
5
Thief (PlayStation 4)
7.5
6
Madden NFL 25 (Xbox One)
7.4
7
Powerstar Golf (Xbox One)
5.8
8
4.0

facebook-follow-us

twitter1

 

Recent comments

Powered by Disqus